Fading West Built the House in Colorado. The Next Stop Is on Oʻahu.

Muncy Homes
Signature
Superior Builders
Premier Builders

The modules came off the barge on a Friday. By Monday, the crew had them set. About a week and a half later, Elijah Davidson, a project manager with Hawaii’s Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, was standing in a painted home with the appliances in place. Somewhere back in Buena Vista, Colorado, was the factory that built it. I’d love to see the production manager’s shipping board for that job.

That house helps explain why a November 15 story in the Honolulu Star-Advertiser caught my attention. Two Hawaii developers, Honolulu’s Nan Inc. and Maui’s Dowling Co., are planning subdivisions that use factory-built homes. Both believe they can deliver quality comparable to conventional construction while cutting time and cost. Fading West gives Hawaii builders something more tangible to consider. They can walk through a Colorado-built house on Oʻahu and ask the people who put it there what the trip actually took.

Maui opened the door. Oʻahu asks a different question.

Fading West had already crossed the Pacific before this house arrived. Following the Maui wildfires, the company produced 82 of the 167 homes in Kilohana, a temporary housing community for survivors. Island crews still had foundations, decks, stairs, and some roof work to complete. That experience gave Fading West a pretty good education in where the Colorado crew’s job ends, and the Hawaii crew’s job begins.

The Oʻahu assignment brings a different customer and a different measure of success. In October, the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands awarded homestead leases to 24 Native Hawaiian families under its first single-family modular pilot. Sixteen lots are in Kapolei, and eight are in Waiʻanae. These are scattered lots, which any modular builder will appreciate. Repeating a floor plan is one thing. Getting the truck, crane, and set crew onto two dozen individual lots is where the local superintendent earns a paycheck.

What does a Colorado house cost when it gets to Hawaii?

Davidson put the three-bedroom, two-bath home at $499,000 and the four-bedroom, three-bath home at $585,600. He cited roughly $670,000 as a market comparison for the larger house. There’s an important detail for anyone tempted to subtract those last two numbers and declare victory for modular. The families received homestead leases. Before I’d credit the factory with the entire difference, I’d want to see a conventionally built house on the same kind of lot, with the same site work and lease terms.

There’s also the price comparison that matters at the family kitchen table. Department Chair Kali Watson said most people on the agency’s waiting list earn less than 60 percent of area median income. A three-bedroom house for under half a million dollars may get a Hawaii builder’s attention. The family still has to carry the monthly payment. When the department reviews this pilot, I hope somebody asks how many families offered one of these homes could afford to say yes.

Could the factory follow the homes?

Watson has expressed interest in establishing a modular factory in Hawaii. Fading West and state officials have discussed local production, and there’s a good reason to take the idea seriously. An island plant could put more of the work in local hands and eliminate the ocean crossing for a finished module. It would also give somebody the responsibility of keeping that plant busy every Monday morning. dhhl.hawaii.gov

Here’s an item I’d put on the agenda before anybody starts shopping for equipment. At a September state housing finance meeting, the team behind a proposed Kailua-Kona project listed three possible suppliers. One was Hawaii’s HPM Building Supply, another was Fading West in Colorado, and the third was TLC Modular in Vietnam. The developer saw value in having choices as freight costs and tariffs change. A prospective factory owner looking at that very same project would be wise to put it in the maybe column until a purchase order arrives.

Gary’s Observation

What I like about Fading West’s entry into Hawaii is the order in which things are happening. The company built homes for Maui. Now families on Oʻahu can walk through a house, open the cabinets, look down the hallway and decide whether they’d like to live there. Meanwhile, people considering a Hawaii factory can learn from every delivery.

Saratoga Modular Homes
Select Modular Homes
Sica Modular Homes
Muncy Homes
Superior Builders
Premier Builders